Since 2014, several countries have introduced legislation to criminalize ‘street harassment.’ In France, this criminalization was framed within a feminist perspective, by conceiving of street harassment as the first level of a ‘continuum of violence against women.’ In the Netherlands, on the other hand, proposals to criminalize these behaviors came from right-wing political parties. They framed ordinances as protecting public order and focused on racialized loitering youth as the main problem group. Despite these differences, proponents of penalization in both countries encountered a similar criticism: according to left-wing politicians, feminists, and anti-racist activists, criminalizing street harassment could lead to disproportionate punishment of racialized men from disadvantaged backgrounds. This article argues for a pragmatic ‘sociology of critique’ within the sociology of law, which provides insight into how actors involved in the introduction of regulation develop reflexivity about the risks of legislation, as well as their blind spots. |
Recht der Werkelijkheid
Meer op het gebied van Algemeen
Over dit tijdschriftMeld u zich hier aan voor de attendering op dit tijdschrift zodat u direct een mail ontvangt als er een nieuw digitaal nummer is verschenen en u de artikelen online kunt lezen.
Redactioneel |
De veelzijdigheid van Recht der Werkelijkheid |
Auteurs | Paulien de Winter |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
De strafbaarstelling van straatintimidatie en het risico van etnisch profilerenEen pragmatische ‘sociologie van kritiek’ |
Trefwoorden | Street Harassment, Feminism, Ethnic profiling, Gender-based violence, Criminalization |
Auteurs | Mischa Dekker |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Inspecteurs met voeten in de kleiEen nieuw model voor controle bij agrarisch natuurbeheer |
Trefwoorden | Agri-environmental governance, Inspection & compliance, Socio-legal, Nature conservation, Self regulation |
Auteurs | Edwin Alblas |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Agri-environmental schemes serve to financially compensate farmers for promoting the quality of nature and landscapes on their land. In 2016, the Netherlands implemented a new scheme that is unique in an EU and even global context. Within this model, rule-setting, inspection and enforcement tasks are shared between public actors and private ‘environmental cooperatives’: groups of farmers legally organized as conservation organizations. |
Discussie |
Complexiteit van multiproblematiek en het probleemoplossend vermogen van de rechter |
Trefwoorden | Multiple problems, Community Courts, Complexity, Problem solving justice |
Auteurs | Marc Simon Thomas |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this essay I problematize the phenomenon of multiple problems. Multiple problems have a threefold complexity: (1) it is complex to deal with for those having these kind of problems, (2) it is complex to deal with for aid workers and others working at problem solving organization, and (3) often the relationship between the aid seeker and the aid worker is full of tension. It is because of this complexity that the role of a judge – as problem solver – is limited. Based on empirical data derived from an (ongoing) socio-legal research on a problem solving court in Rotterdam, the Netherlands, this essay provides insight in what kind of impact a judge’s decision actually can have. |
Forum |
Over vertrouwen, wantrouwen en gemakzuchtige oordeelsvorming |
Auteurs | Lucas Noyon |
Auteursinformatie |
Forum |
Over het vertrouwen van ‘de’ burger |
Auteurs | Hilke Grootelaar |
Auteursinformatie |
Recensies en signalementen |
Systematisch kijken naar excuses in het recht |
Auteurs | Chris Reinders Folmer |
Auteursinformatie |
Recensies en signalementen |
De beste behandeling van een bezwaar: Over de vorm en de inhoud |
Auteurs | Teun Geurts |
Auteursinformatie |
Werk in uitvoering |
Researching racialisation: the regulation of interracialised intimacies in France (1954-1979) |
Trefwoorden | France, Interracial intimacies, Migration, Gender, Race |
Auteurs | Rébecca Franco |
Auteursinformatie |