This article examines the impact of the introduction of the Schutznorm-principle (relativiteitsvereiste) in the Dutch General Administrative Law Act on the private enforcement of state aid law. This principle prohibits the administrative courts to annul a decision if the ground manifestly does not protect the complainants interests. Court decisions are examined to research the role of individuals in the private enforcement of state aid law. These individuals often have no competitive relation with the (alleged) beneficiary of the aid. However, presumably the Schutznorm-principle will not hinder them from annulling the decision because the Schutznorm-principle requires clarity regarding the scope of the provision invoked. Article 108 TFEU lacks this clarity. Based on possibilities of appeal against Commissions decisions and case law of the EU CoJ on this matter, the author argues that not every individual needs to be able to invoke state aid provisions. |
Netherlands Administrative Law Library
Meer in rechtsgebied Bestuursrecht, Open Access
Over dit tijdschriftArticle (without peer review) |
Staatssteunrecht gerelativeerd - Het bestuursrechtelijke relativiteitsvereiste bezien in het licht van staatssteunrecht |
Auteurs | Matthijs Baart |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Article (without peer review) |
Transparantie en mededinging in het Nederlandse bestuursrecht: van opdrachten, via concessies naar vergunningen? |
Auteurs | Annemarie Drahmann |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In its Betfair judgment, the Court of Justice ruled that the exclusive license system with respect to games of chance under Dutch law breaches Article 49 of the EC, now: Article 56 of the TFEU, concerning the free movement of services, and in particular the principle of equal treatment and the obligation of transparency. This article addresses the lessons which can be drawn from this judgement and which Dutch legal concepts could be applied to this 'European' obligation of transparency. According to the judgement, this is not only the case for 'public contracts'and 'concessions', but also to licenses under public law. This article addresses the meaning of these legal concepts and discusses to what extent this 'European' obligation of transparency applies to the relevant Dutch legal concepts. |